Welcome GUEST!      CREATE ACCOUNT - Forgot Password?

Create an account to share your experiences and more!


Auto Log-in Future Sessions (on this computer).
User Comment A note about the site and any replies from other users.

Visit I Dream Of Jo

I Dream Of Jo (0)

messmer (137) 06-02-13  11:23am
Rookie Badge  Talk Back  Comments  Pollster  Top Monthly User  Hardcore Badge  Trusted User  Male Profile TRUST USER?   YES (72), NO (1)

In defense of the Jo fans!

They remind me of myself, five years ago. I had subscribed to an erotic site for the first time and it blew me away. I let the webmaster know how much I liked her (his) site and Abby (Winters) suggested that I publish my high opinion in Porn Users. Of course, I did not do a review but made a comment instead. I did not see myself as a shill for the site and saw nothing wrong with it. If I remember right, quite a few climbed all over me for that. BTW, I am still grateful to Abby Winters for sending me here.

Reply To Comment

Comment Replies (6)

Replies to the user comment above.

Msg # User Message Date


pat362 (375) I checked your first review in 2007 of AW and the one you did in 2011 and they aren't comparable because they are like night and day. The original one had no data. There's nothing wrong per say but is that really a review or just a fan talking about his favorite site.

I would have been fine if one person had made a review of Jo's site and picked a score that was at least close to what TBP gave the site but you got 3 people in a row who scored the site at 95, 98 and 100 and none of them could actually say anything except that the content is artistic(what does that even mean?). There is now a 4th review but we finally see a score that makes sense and there is info that is important to someone who wants to make an educated choice.

I don't know if the reviews were planted by someone associated with the site but 4 reviews in a 3 day period of a site that had none looks suspicious.

06-02-13  12:05pm

Reply To Message


messmer (137) REPLY TO #1 - pat362 :

Oops, you know I had no idea that I did a review, Pat. I thought it was a comment. Must go back to see what I wrote at the time! :-) In any case, I agree, when I saw all those very short reviews with high marks .. for ONE site ... my suspicion meter went way up as well. I'm just saying that fans of a site, in their enthusiasm for it, may write a very inadequate review at the suggestion of a web master without being shills. Just sincerely in love with it.
06-02-13  12:28pm

Reply To Message


pat362 (375) REPLY TO #2 - messmer :

I can't accuse them of the crime and I don't want to but we wouldn't be talking about this if it had been only one review. We got 4 new reviews of a site that had none and 3 of them were so bad that the info and score are not to be taken seriously.

At least the last review is dead on and that's the one I will use to make a decision.

06-02-13  06:21pm

Reply To Message


RagingBuddhist (65) Well, I'm the forever skeptic and, especially now that there's a fifth "review" up, I don't like what I see. Having someone associated with a site send their members to do reviews reeks of free advertising. And I doubt I'm the only one who's wondering if there's been any sort of compensation for putting up the high marks.
06-02-13  08:02pm

Reply To Message


messmer (137) REPLY TO #4 - RagingBuddhist :

No doubt Abby Winters wanted some free advertising at the time but I was a willing participant and no, I never expected compensation nor did I get any. I was just glad to spread the Gospel of, what I thought was a great site at the time. I do agree, however, that a flood of extremely short, favourable reviews, might make one suspicious!
06-02-13  10:06pm

Reply To Message


messmer (137) REPLY TO #3 - pat362 :

I agree about the last review, Pat!
06-02-13  10:10pm

Reply To Message

*Message rows highlighted in light orange are replies to replies.

Home - Sites - Users - Reviews - Comments - Categories - Forum

Contact Us - Announcements - FAQ's - Terms & Rules - Porn Review - Webmasters

Protecting Minors
We are strong supporters of RTA and ICRA, two of the most recognized self labeling organizations. Our site is properly labeled to assist in the protection of minors accessing inappopriate content. For information about filtering tools, check this site.


To report child pornography, go directly to ASACP!  We're proud to be a corporate sponsor.
Have concerns or questions about porn addiction?  We recommend this helpful resource.

Copyright © 2007 Ranks.com, Inc. and its licensors. All Rights Reserved.

Loaded in 0.01 seconds.