Amateur Girls Reviews & Comments
Top Sites
|
Top rated and most active sites in the niche. |
Top Rated
No Sites Found.
|
|
Most Active
No Sites Found.
|
New Reviews
|
Latest 3 user reviews in this niche. |
1. Nebraska Coeds (0)
Pay |
|
| Status: |
Current Member for over 1 month (at the time of review).
|
| Pros: |
Super amateur site that has been around a long time
Very high quality downloads, almost too high
Pictures are downloadable in sets
Daily updates
Believable amateur college women
Party-style settings on scenes |
| Cons: |
Those high quality videos will be the end of your hard drive if you download too many of them. The biggest file sizes I have seen.
The site is dated and could use a better interface |
| Bottom Line: |
Nebraska Coeds has been around longer than most of us have had 5G or fiber internet and probably longer than most of us have had computers. It makes the massive file size downloads seem questionable, but who am I to say a site shouldn’t offer the best possible quality downloads? You get two options for video downloads and those are 1080p and 4K. The bitrates are the highest I have ever seen and some scenes are over 20GB each. I’m not posting that as a negative, but am posting it for anyone who has a slow internet connection. I just have the lower-tier cable internet in my area and the bigger scenes take around 20 minutes each to download. If a person was using a slower connection, I could see the bigger scenes taking hours to download.
There isn’t much of a theme to the scenes other than college girls being horny and wild. The models are pretty or cute but there is not a lot of difference in body types or skin color. The scenes do not seem heavily produced or directed. You do get some feeling of the women are in control and just doing what feels natural.
There is a high amount of tease content to build up for the more hardcore scenes and you’re going to see a lot of multiple women scenes, three is a common number for these scenes and those are really great. There are solo scenes too. The categories are useful to find specific scenarios you might prefer. I have seen videos from what is supposed to be a library, in public, in bathrooms and so on. All the bases are covered.
I believe the models being believable college women and amateurs is extremely important to the site’s popularity. Both the amateur and college women genres have been used by porn for decades and lied about to sell porn. This site is the most believable authentic college woman site I have ever been a member of.
The one con about the file size is really not a big con for me. I download the 1080p videos and am more than happy with those. The other con is just a familiarity I have with the site. It doesn’t feel like the site has changed anything about it in years. That is a con since the site just feels like new scenes are added and nothing is being changed or improved other than the new content.
Neither con is enough of a problem to take off much from the score. The site still is exactly what it says and it may be the best example of a college amateur women site available. The big files can be avoided or you can become selective or buy more external hard drives. You’re just not likely to find scenes of this quality of real amateur college women and that is the most important pro or con of the site.
The icing on the cake is you get daily updates. It is easily one of my favorite amateur sites if not my absolute favorite. |
| Respond: |
0 Replies
- Add Reply
|
|
2. Abby Winters (0)
Pay |
|
| Status: |
Current Member for over 1 month (at the time of review).
|
| Pros: |
Prior to their move from Australia, this site was one of the very best anywhere. The stuff in their archives from this period is extraordinary.
After you logon, in the top right, it tells you how many days until your next rebill.
Lots of content – 1984 models, 7049 shoots. |
| Cons: |
Starting in June 2023, they stopped making any new shoots. This is announced on their internal forum. They are still posting one update a week, but the backlog will have to run dry at some point.
The regular monthly subscription is expensive, and the discount for longer terms is minimal.
Updates are only 1 per week.
Many models have had their content removed, at their request.
You need to give 7 days notice to cancel your subscription rebill. But otherwise it was easy. |
| Bottom Line: |
I have to give credit to KayTBuffs for talking me into signing up for this site again, and I am super glad I did.
Providing a score for this site is kind of tough. For the version in Australia (up to 2010), I’d give it 100. It was darn near perfect. For the version in Europe up to 2023 (while they were still doing photo shoots), I’d give it 88. For the most recent version, I’d give it an 80.
Especially during the period where they were based in Australia, the site emphasized fun more than anything else. It didn’t have to necessarily be sexual fun, just naked fun (the best kind)! I think they also got some of their models via a couple of girl friends (not necessarily lesbian lovers, just girls that are friends) who would sign up along the lines of “I’ll do it if you’ll do it.” There are a lot of girls with only one shoot and then they are done – they got the rush of thousands of paying customers signing up to look at their naked body, hopefully enjoyed their time in the buff, and have returned to normal life.
I think part of the attraction for a site like this is that most of these women fall into the category of “pretty” rather than “super model”. These girls feel like they are in my league – like if I asked them out they’d probably say yes, assuming they are currently not in a relationship. And based on the fun they are having in their photo shoot, I’d expect to have fun with them on a date.
Models can request that their content be removed. Abby Winters will honor that request, although if they appear in a group, then that content will usually still be on line. As a human being, I can certainly understand this and applaud them for doing so. Their sets go back to 2000, so some of these ladies are now mothers with kids in school, and it can definitely be awkward for junior to have his/her classmates comment on Mom’s porn career. But as a porn purchaser, it is disappointing to see that some of my favorites no longer appear on the site.
One thing I enjoyed as I looked through the archives, the Girls Down Under tended to keep their feminine furriness intact Down There. So many beautiful bushes in one place was a real treat.
There are over 3000 different tags you can search on. It isn’t obvious how to get to the Advanced Search though. The search bar on the main page will only search for models by name. But you can type in just about anything, and when it comes back with nothing found, they will present some random shoots for you to look at. There is now also an Advanced button, and if you click that button, you will have more options.
Alternatively, go to abbywinters.com/tags and you will get a (very long) list of every tag that has been used as a tag on the site. You can break that down a little bit, by Model Tags, Shoot Tags, Video Tags, or Image Tags. Then click on a tag, and it shows you everything that had that tag applied. These are mostly user-supplied tags, and spelling (and misspelling) matters. For example clicking on the Model Tag for “fair skin” returned 240 models. Of course, a model might actually have fair skin but not be tagged this way, or she doesn’t have fair skin so was tagged incorrectly. But it’s not a bad feature to check out.
The ”fetishes” section is a nice feature. “We call activities and aspects of our models "fetishes" because we cannot think of a better word.” These are curated collections centered around something like Girls in Dresses, Topless in Jeans, Tan Lines, Natural Redhead, Glasses on Naked Girls, Full Body Standing Nude, Large Natural Breasts, Tiny Breasts, Rubenesque, etc.
The Boy-Girl stuff on the site is pretty unique – these are actual real-life boyfriend and girlfriend.
Some porn royalty have appeared on the site. Katya Clover (as Caramel S), Ryana, Eve Sweet to name a few.
A pointer – when you go to sign up, scroll down a bit on the home page to find the Deal of the Day. These deals rotate every 24 hours. Most of the time it offers 10% off on a membership. Some times it offers bonus credits in case you would rather buy only a few sets rather than do a full membership. And occasionally there will be an offer for buy one month, get a second month free – that is the one I used when I signed up.
Bottom line – I highly recommend this site to anyone, especially if you can get the buy-one-month-get-one-free deal. No telling how much longer this site will be around.
Also , a bit of history:
2010 – The Company was charged and found guilty of “producing material a reasonable adult might find offensive,” a crime in the state of Victoria (Australia). This caused them to relocate business and staff to the Netherlands. Also starting in 2010, all videos were released in HD1080. Then starting in 2020, videos were released in 4K. |
| Respond: |
0 Replies
- Add Reply
|
|
3. Abby Winters (0)
Pay |
|
| Status: |
Current Member for over 1 year (at the time of review).
|
| Pros: |
My favorite site for the last 7 years
There is solo, lesbian and male/female sex
The models are either amateurs or I don’t know them
You get unlimited downloads of pictures and videos
Beautiful real women of different races, hair colors and body shapes
Navigation is great, but I have been a member off and on for 7 years
Quality of videos, pictures, production are all very high
The videos are long in a good way |
| Cons: |
The only con I can think of and it’s just for the in-general potential member – the price is more than the average site at $39.95 per month |
| Bottom Line: |
Abby Winters is a site that exemplifies a top porn site! It has the best realism in porn – for my money. The models are of all types. You will see slim, medium, slightly more than medium women. The hair colors are all over the rainbow. Tattoos aren’t common for the women, but more common for their boyfriends. Their hardcore scenes are mostly of a female model with her real-life boyfriend. The sex is passionate, sometimes dirty, especially the lesbian scenes and you aren’t likely to see anything that makes you feel like it’s faked or scripted.
When I first joined Abby Winters back in 2009, I remember it mostly or even exclusively being women. I joined it every year from 2009 to 2018, but in 2018, I started joining it more and it became my favorite site. The girls with their boyfriends series is, in my opinion, the best hardcore male/female porn available . It’s mostly just straightforward sex between the male and female, but there are some kinkier scenes. The girl/girl scenes are and have been my favorite scenes on the site. It’s not always about jump into a 69 or start tribbing furiously. Some of the girl/girl scenes are of two women sitting beside each other on a couch and masturbating. I’m still convinced that is how straight women find themselves in an unexpected bisexual situation, or how bi-curiosity starts. I’m convinced their scenes are not scripted. Maybe the first second is scripted. You know, like – the two women sit on the couch beside each other, both with intentions of masturbating, but that’s where I believe the scripting stops. The Girls with their Boyfriends series doesn’t need to be debated whether it’s scripted. I am sure the producer just tells them to have sex like they normally would. The solo scenes are very good, too.
Quality is an easy pro on Abby Winters. The videos, especially newer ones are available in 4K downloads. Most of the videos are at least offered in 720p and 1080p. You can download the pictures, which are equally as impressive as the videos, in zip files. There are no download limits if you subscribe. There are a couple updates every week. The site is huge with a combined close to 12,000 videos and picture sets. The videos are higher in number, too.
The pricing is the only con I listed and I only listed it because I know others might balk at that price. You can buy individual scenes if you want, but the subscription is the way to go for me. I can’t imagine only wanting 1 or 2 scenes. If the price is the only thing stopping from joining, there are promos that reduce the price.
Realism in porn is only so-so important to me. That is because I have an active imagination. Seeing these scenes that are undeniably real, it just makes it easier for me to enjoy. I have to use my imagination with most porn and it’s Abby Winters videos that show me I’m probably not enjoying other porn sites as much as I think – or imagined.
This site is based in Australia and outside of a couple sites, I don’t think there are but a few Australian porn sites. That helps the models seem like all amateurs or they really are all amateurs. Several of the models look familiar, but I can’t say for sure why.
This is the best site for me. Anytime my subscription runs out, I take a month or so to join other sites, and even without an active membership, I still find myself clicking on my Abby Winters bookmark, more times than not, rejoining it as soon as I do.
I can’t recommend any other site over it. |
| Respond: |
4 Replies
- Add Reply
|
|
*Newbie reviews and ratings don't count toward a site's overall score/rank until the user reaches the Rookie status level (5 points). This rule is needed to help prevent fake (or heavily biased) profiles and reviews.
View All: New Reviews
|
New Comments
|
Latest 3 user comments in this niche. |
|
|
|
