Amateur Girls Reviews & Comments
Top Sites
|
Top rated and most active sites in the niche. |
Top Rated
No Sites Found.
|
|
Most Active
No Sites Found.
|
New Reviews
|
Latest 3 user reviews in this niche. |

1. Abby Winters (0)
Pay |
|
Status: |
Current Member for over 1 year (at the time of review).
|
Pros: |
My favorite site for the last 7 years
There is solo, lesbian and male/female sex
The models are either amateurs or I don’t know them
You get unlimited downloads of pictures and videos
Beautiful real women of different races, hair colors and body shapes
Navigation is great, but I have been a member off and on for 7 years
Quality of videos, pictures, production are all very high
The videos are long in a good way |
Cons: |
The only con I can think of and it’s just for the in-general potential member – the price is more than the average site at $39.95 per month |
Bottom Line: |
Abby Winters is a site that exemplifies a top porn site! It has the best realism in porn – for my money. The models are of all types. You will see slim, medium, slightly more than medium women. The hair colors are all over the rainbow. Tattoos aren’t common for the women, but more common for their boyfriends. Their hardcore scenes are mostly of a female model with her real-life boyfriend. The sex is passionate, sometimes dirty, especially the lesbian scenes and you aren’t likely to see anything that makes you feel like it’s faked or scripted.
When I first joined Abby Winters back in 2009, I remember it mostly or even exclusively being women. I joined it every year from 2009 to 2018, but in 2018, I started joining it more and it became my favorite site. The girls with their boyfriends series is, in my opinion, the best hardcore male/female porn available . It’s mostly just straightforward sex between the male and female, but there are some kinkier scenes. The girl/girl scenes are and have been my favorite scenes on the site. It’s not always about jump into a 69 or start tribbing furiously. Some of the girl/girl scenes are of two women sitting beside each other on a couch and masturbating. I’m still convinced that is how straight women find themselves in an unexpected bisexual situation, or how bi-curiosity starts. I’m convinced their scenes are not scripted. Maybe the first second is scripted. You know, like – the two women sit on the couch beside each other, both with intentions of masturbating, but that’s where I believe the scripting stops. The Girls with their Boyfriends series doesn’t need to be debated whether it’s scripted. I am sure the producer just tells them to have sex like they normally would. The solo scenes are very good, too.
Quality is an easy pro on Abby Winters. The videos, especially newer ones are available in 4K downloads. Most of the videos are at least offered in 720p and 1080p. You can download the pictures, which are equally as impressive as the videos, in zip files. There are no download limits if you subscribe. There are a couple updates every week. The site is huge with a combined close to 12,000 videos and picture sets. The videos are higher in number, too.
The pricing is the only con I listed and I only listed it because I know others might balk at that price. You can buy individual scenes if you want, but the subscription is the way to go for me. I can’t imagine only wanting 1 or 2 scenes. If the price is the only thing stopping from joining, there are promos that reduce the price.
Realism in porn is only so-so important to me. That is because I have an active imagination. Seeing these scenes that are undeniably real, it just makes it easier for me to enjoy. I have to use my imagination with most porn and it’s Abby Winters videos that show me I’m probably not enjoying other porn sites as much as I think – or imagined.
This site is based in Australia and outside of a couple sites, I don’t think there are but a few Australian porn sites. That helps the models seem like all amateurs or they really are all amateurs. Several of the models look familiar, but I can’t say for sure why.
This is the best site for me. Anytime my subscription runs out, I take a month or so to join other sites, and even without an active membership, I still find myself clicking on my Abby Winters bookmark, more times than not, rejoining it as soon as I do.
I can’t recommend any other site over it. |
Respond: |
4 Replies
- Add Reply
|
|


2. Girls Out West (0)
Pay |
|
Status: |
Current Member for over 1 month (at the time of review).
|
Pros: |
The most realistic porn site for me
The models are treated as women before than as models
Plenty of high resolution downloads and no limit that I know of
Picture sets are some of the best I have seen
Updates nearly daily
The models come in all different sizes, races, builds, hair colors |
Cons: |
The navigation is good enough, but it does get frustrating at times
Because the models are different in so many ways, it could be a problem if you only prefer one or two types of models |
Bottom Line: |
Girls Out West offers the most realistic porn for my money. I believe that could be a problem for some, but for me, it’s my favorite part. The women go from slim to medium to heavy, all hair colors, even the personalities of each model show. You might not like every model, but it will be hard to convince me you don’t like at least some of the models. The sex scenes, mostly lesbian, feature what I see as real sex. The moans sound real. The reactions are real. The women themselves seem real too. I believe when you’re filming mostly amateurs you have the advantage of the models not having to live up (or down to) an image. Just like there were known models who were very vocal and even loud. You don’t get that on Girls Out West. These models react how they would in real life.
The updates are very good. You will see an average of 5-6 new scenes per week. That is in addition to the nearly 6,000 videos the site already has. Girls Out West is the one site that makes me think amateur models are far better off with minimal scripts. I don’t know what all goes into that, but the women look to be having genuine fun, experiencing real passion and having orgasms.
The realism is really stronger in the non-sexual parts. You can see the chemistry the models have together before the clothes come off. They laugh, they pick on each other, you can even pick up the eye contact and the moment their minds shift to sex. There are other sites that offer a similar experience, but I believe Girls Out West has it figured out more than any site. I just don’t believe it is that easy to create passion the viewer can feel. Not every Girls Out West scene does that. I am going to guess and say at least half the scenes I have watched were strong on passion.
I do believe the different model types could be a slight problem for some people. We wouldn’t have genres focusing on specific body types if body types or even ethnicity wasn’t an important part. I will go as far as saying it’s often the most important part to a porn fan. The models on Girls Out West are very different – even scene to scene. But, because I value realism in my porn, I accept not every model is going to match my preferences.
There’s nothing really wrong with the navigation. I find problems when searching in the older scenes, but I can’t offer a suggestion on how to make it better. I believe it’s because the site has been around for over 25 years.
When I said, in the pros, women are treated as women before they are treated as models, that just means, the women are treated as real and with emotions. It’s my belief a model is directly related to an actress. No one, at least I hope not, gets up everyday and turns into a model everyday. There has to be a certain level of acting for a human to see themselves or present themselves as a model. I never thought mindfulness would be an important part of porn, but it sure makes it more enjoyable.
You can download the videos and photo sets. The videos look great on my monitor and the picture sets are as good as the videos. I have found myself surprised by some of the scenes I ended up liking. I attribute the surprise to me thinking I would only like videos with a model with a specific build or ethnicity. It is the strength of the site. The models are happy and are enjoying themselves. I do believe that is something lost in most porn. I would rather see a model who doesn’t match my preferences, but is enjoying herself than a model who matches my preferences, but seems miserable. It is one of those sites I believe deserves a round of applause. |
Respond: |
1 Reply
- Add Reply
|
|


3. Naughty Natural (0)
Pay |
|
Status: |
Current Member for over 1 month (at the time of review).
|
Pros: |
Possibly the most polarizing “hairy” site I have ever been a member of
Is owned and operated by my favourite hairy model – Nikki Silver
New update every 3 days
Includes access to their Only Fans account
Over 1000 videos and all are downloadable with some even having 4K resolution so you are sure not to miss a single hair
Women of all sizes and ages; topped only by the variations of hairiness from facial, arms, legs, armpits and bushes |
Cons: |
Monthly download limit does severely limit how much content you get to keep.
I called it polarizing because even for a fan of hairy and natural women, some of the hairy examples on the site are just too much for even me. |
Bottom Line: |
A lot of natural and hairy sites are out there and most are just minor escapades into the world of hirsute femininity. I have joined some hairy or natural sites that are only showing hairy pubic areas. Naughty Natural goes all the way left with their hairiness.
Nikki Silver, sometimes spelled as Nikkie, is the featured model and owns the site. If you have not heard of Nikki, there is a good chance, this site may be too hairy for you. Nikki is one of the top hairy models across the world. She does have hair in places we do not usually associate with femininity. This includes her armpits, pubic area and inner thighs. I do believe she is in the top 1% of attractive hairy models and believe you could judge your own tolerance towards hairy models by looking up some of Nikki’s content and seeing if you are attracted or off put.
One of my favourite parts of hirsute porn is the inclusion of hair in often taboo (by mainstream standards) areas of the female body, means heavy, overweight, large breasted women fit right into the site and niche. Much like their slimmer, ultra hairy peers, the larger women can fit in by matching the taboo hairy parts.
We should talk about the download limit. The download limit will limit you to downloading 10-15 videos per month! I am willing to admit, I am such a fan of Nikki, I almost exclusively just download her scenes. See con #2 for a sort of explanation for why I focus on Nikki’s videos. While I am a fan of hairy models, there is a line for me and Nikki is that line. She is nowhere near as extreme on the hairiness of some of the other models. I do find an appeal to all the content and it probably has something to do with not being normal or status quo. I enjoy seeing different body types, varying body hair locations and everything that is similar to how regular, everyday life is. I know when I was single and dating, I remember the feeling of excitement, maybe a little fear, arousal, when a new woman in my life first took her clothes off in front of me. Naughty Natural offers that kind of experience just by scanning from one model to the next. If you ever are in a porn rut of thinking every model looks alike or feel like you are watching models modeled after one specific look, a site like Naughty Natural can give you a breath of fresh air and new interest even.
The site works and navigates well. I consider it important in this genre. I only knew a handful of the models by name. Nikki really stands out for me with natural, very curvy body and pretty face, the hair only highlights her pluses, including her beautiful complexion. The other models are all attractive in their own way and the scenes – if curious, are focused more on the beauty and attractiveness of the female form than on hardcore sex. You might want to make a note about that. If you are looking for hardcore sex you will not find it on here. There are some strap on lesbian scenes and even all-girl group scenes.
The download limit does put a limit on the ceiling or how high I can score the site. Maybe if they just lifted the limit to 25-30 downloads per month, one per day – minimally, to be fully acceptable, to me. I often find myself making a text list of the scenes and rating them to know which ones I should use by limited downloads on. That is, at least for me, a fairly big con and negative. I am not for sure what the site would score with more downloads or even unlimited downloads, but I have to believe a 92 even with a severe download limit, has to be considered very good and it is. My only other question is if the site just had Nikki Silver content would the score be the same? It is very possible, but I do like having the other models and variations of hairiness. Great site for all, and a must join for fans of hairy models. |
Respond: |
0 Replies
- Add Reply
|
|

*Newbie reviews and ratings don't count toward a site's overall score/rank until the user reaches the Rookie status level (5 points). This rule is needed to help prevent fake (or heavily biased) profiles and reviews.
View All: New Reviews
|
New Comments
|
Latest 3 user comments in this niche. |
|
|
|